Picture this: You’re in the boardroom, pitching a case for modernizing performance management, only to hear the same refrain—“But our process works fine.”
That’s the reality many HR leaders face, with 88% of executives believing their performance management processes are effective, according to the 2024 State of Performance Enablement report. Meanwhile, nearly half of employees (44%) would fail their company’s current approach.
Bridging this disconnect starts with showing your colleagues what HR leaders and employees already know: Annual reviews don’t move the needle. Modern performance management is the solution—but how do you help your skeptical colleagues see its strategic value?
Let’s walk through how to shine a line on the cracks in outdated systems and position performance management as a critical driver of business success.
4 ways modern performance management transforms business outcomes
Not all performance management processes are created equal.
Outdated approaches often rely on rigid, one-size-fits-all reviews that focus on compliance instead of growth. Modern performance management, on the other hand, emphasizes ongoing feedback, regular check-ins, and continuous conversations to deliver ongoing employee performance with measurable results.
Here are four key benefits modern performance management brings to the table.
Makes cross-team collaboration effortless
Cross-functional alignment isn’t just important—it’s essential. But outdated systems with annual check-ins leave teams disjointed and struggling to achieve shared goals. Sporadic reviews and rigid processes — the most common performance management mistakes — don’t provide the clarity employees need to hit those goals.
That’s where modern performance management comes in. By using real-time updates, continuous feedback, and dynamic goal-setting, you create an environment where collaboration happens naturally. Teams stay focused, aligned, and connected to your company’s strategy.
For example, The Driving Force Group launched a five-year “Mission to Mars” initiative, and good performance management made all the difference. With Betterworks, they gave employees a clear line of sight into top-level goals. The result? 88% of employees now understand exactly how their work contributes to the company’s mission.
When teams know how their work fits into the big picture, everything changes. They collaborate seamlessly, take ownership of their goals, and stay motivated to achieve more. And for your organization, that means higher accountability, better results, and unstoppable momentum.
Enables agility in a fast-moving world
Agility isn’t a buzzword—it’s a survival skill. Modern performance management empowers employees to pivot with shifting priorities, stay productive, and thrive in fast-moving environments.
Consider Intuit: Amid a significant business transformation, Intuit opted to use continuous feedback to empower teams to help teams adapt in real time. “The pace of change in technology is … so fast,” said Humera Shahid, chief diversity, equity, and inclusion officer and talent development leader at Intuit, during an EmpowerHR session. “Doing something once a year doesn’t fully reflect or appreciate everything that happens in this fast-moving environment.”
Employees asked for more frequent feedback, and Intuit responded by prioritizing frequent feedback and continuous performance management. The result? Teams stayed aligned, empowered, and productive—even during periods of rapid transformation.
Modern performance management isn’t just about keeping up; it’s about staying ahead. By prioritizing agility, you’ll help your organization adapt to challenges and seize opportunities as they arise.
“This is a time where we can now talk about company and individual performance together,” Humera said. “So we took advantage of the business and what our employees were saying and went on this journey of performance enablement.”
Drives culture change through measurable outcomes
Old-school performance management systems don’t drive growth—they stall it. Annual reviews and generic metrics might keep the compliance box checked, but they rarely influence the deeper changes that fuel long-term success.
Modern performance management flips the script. By aligning individual goals with company values and tracking progress through measurable outcomes, it builds a culture of accountability and transparency. Ongoing conversations between managers and their employees strengthen relationships and build trust, a sense of belonging, and a feeling of being listened to and valued. Senior leadership gains the tools to celebrate successes, address areas for improvement, and ensure alignment—all in real time.
The impact is tangible: higher employee engagement, more cohesive teams, and stronger alignment with strategic objectives. For leadership, this translates into more productive team members and measurable boosts to the bottom line.
Turns data into smarter decisions
With outdated performance management, leaders are stuck playing a guessing game with half-baked data—a risky move when big decisions are on the line. This reactive approach slows decision-making and can lead to missed opportunities.
Modern performance management uses real-time performance metrics to change the game. With instant insights into productivity, employee sentiment, and progress toward goals, leaders can make faster, evidence-based decisions.
Paul Agustin, senior director of solutions engineering at Betterworks, compares it to how many people have integrated health data into their daily lives. “Every couple of days I’m checking to see the trends. … Are there things that I need to be focusing on?” he says. “It’s the same thing in terms of organizations and managers. This gives you a way to take a look at your people data, and make calls on what you need to focus on.”
By embedding data-driven decision-making into daily operations, you can identify skill gaps, refine succession planning, uncover and correct trouble spots, and guide training investments, to name a few. The result? Every decision supports both your organization’s long-term strategy and its day-to-day success.
4 tips for communicating performance management as a strategic asset
Winning leadership buy-in starts with one simple shift: Position performance management as the answer to business challenges, not just another HR program. Here’s how:
Focus on ROI and strategic value
Presenting performance management as a way to achieve strategic business objectives makes it easier for leaders to connect the investment to the big picture while encouraging employee engagement.
Choose the HR metrics that matter most for your organization’s goals. Let the business strategy guide you, writes Jamie Aitken, vice president of HR transformation at Betterworks, in “3 Steps to Making the Business Case for HR Transformation.” For example, if cutting costs is a big focus, highlight metrics like efficiency, cost savings, and time saved. If your company is merging with another, include metrics that show how well employees are aligning with the shared mission and goals.
Frame performance management as a solution to business pain points
Connect performance management to the challenges that keep your colleagues awake at night. For instance, if retaining top talent is a concern, explain how regular feedback sessions improve employee engagement and retention. Highlight how performance management supports team collaboration, aligns individual goals with organizational priorities, and mitigates risks such as burnout or disengagement.
Leverage success stories, backed by data
Nothing is more persuasive than real-world examples. Share success stories from other organizations that have implemented modern performance management practices. Use data to back up your claims.
For instance, by implementing an effective performance management system, Grupo Posadas, a hotel and resort operator, achieved 97% adoption of objectives and key results (OKRs), aligning employees with company priorities. This alignment helped the organization surpass financial goals, including exceeding revenue targets and increasing revenue per available room (RevPAR) by 13%. Seeing how other organizations achieved real revenue impact can go a long way toward making your case.
Internal pilot programs can also serve as proof of concept. If one team achieves measurable success, use it as a case study to illustrate the potential impact across the organization.
Keep your pitch brief and results-oriented
When making your case to the leadership team, focus on outcomes rather than processes. For example, instead of explaining the mechanics of a new performance management software, emphasize how it will drive long-term growth by improving decision-making, increasing agility, or boosting employee engagement.
Use visuals like charts or infographics to illustrate key points. A concise, visually compelling presentation is more likely to resonate with decision-makers.
Discover how top organizations drive results with smarter performance strategies
Modern performance management has the power to align goals, foster collaboration, and deliver measurable results. By embracing continuous feedback and clear communication, you can empower your employees to drive business success while keeping your organization agile and innovative.
Want to learn more? Discover 7 Examples of How to Drive Workforce Transformation With Modern Performance Management.
Discover how Betterworks’ customers are leading workforce transformations
